I-1082 Will Stabilize Worker’s Compensation in Washington



Oct. 13, 2010 –


Washington state will benefit three ways if Initiative 1082 passes, according to the highly respected Washington Policy Center (WPC).

WPC released a study that shows I-1082 will “help keep premium increases in check, encourage innovation in rehabilitating injured workers, and most importantly, provide safer workplaces.” That means employers and workers will benefit.

The WPC points out the four goals of I-1082:

  1. Maintain existing benefit levels for injured workers while improving their opportunity to return to work.
  2. Eliminate the requirement that workers pay one-half of their medical coverage for on-the-job injuries.
  3. Open up the current state-run industrial insurance system to competition from private industrial insurance providers, with a July 1, 2012 start date for an open market.
  4. Maintain a “best practices” approach to worker safety as developed by both private and public sectors

The WPC study (Citizens Guide to Initiative 1082: To Reform Workers’ Compensation in Washington) concludes that Washington state is a “high benefit, high cost state system.”

It explains how the current government system “is on a shaky financial footing.”

The study also asserts “punishes a business community that has produced safer workplaces over the last two decades, and has been rewarded with steadily increasing insurance rates.”

The study’s most salient points:

  1. Research shows that more competition in industrial insurance would help keep premiums in check, encourage innovation in rehabilitating injured workers and provide safer workplaces.
  2. States that have recently introduced a competitive industrial insurance market have seen costs decline and customer satisfaction increase.
  3. As written, I-1082 relieves employees from paying for industrial insurance premiums. As in the other 49 states, businesses would pay 100% of the cost.
  4. I-1082 would not address every detail of the transition to a “hybrid” industrial insurance market, but would set mechanisms in place to do so.
  5. As written, I-1082 does not alter the benefit levels of injured workers in any way.

Proponents argue that Washington state is only one of four state-government monopolies in the nation. They lament Washington’s worker’s comp increases while Oregon has had the same rates for the last two decades. They point to the state’s second-highest cost per worker, and “the third most generous benefit package in the nation.”

From the Coach’s Corner, for more information, here are three I-1082 resource links:


How to Alleviate Business Uncertainty in Washington State



 July 25, 2010


Washington state is comparatively healthy. But don’t tell that to most employers. They won’t buy it. Washington state has lost more jobs, 16,000, in the past year than 41 other states.

Unemployment rates are a huge drag holding back economic development. There are many reasons why job creation is sputtering.

Actually, it’s symptomatic and related to many economic problems. The overall common denominator is uncertainty – from declining sales revenue, threats of a double-dip recession, tax increases, and unproductive public policies.

Yes, Washington faces another $3 billion shortfall.

A July Op Ed piece in the Seattle Times by State Auditor Brian Sonntag made an excellent case for decreasing the size of state government and improving its inefficient budgeting process.

“We need to resize government’s footprint to reflect what it can and should do, balanced with what it can afford to do,” Mr. Sonntag wrote. “We will not get there unless we stop, now, the petty partisan bickering that erodes citizens’ trust in government and inhibits meaningful solutions to our greatest challenges.”

A frequent complaint on this site is the mega unfunded public pensions. Mr. Sonntag points out Washington state public pensions are skyrocketing and $8 billion is unfunded.

“Our work at the Office of State Auditor uniquely positions us to understand the state’s broad financial condition,” Mr. Sonntag explained. “For example, we know even in good economic times as well as bad, the state has not systematically funded all its long-term financial obligations.”

It’s not just the unfunded aspects of pensions, which I contend are too generous vis-à-vis the retirement plans available in the private sector.

Mr. Sonntag cited a related example: “A $4 billion liability in the health-and life-insurance benefits paid to retired public employees without any accumulation of revenue to pay for it.”

Political “courage” and “leadership” is needed, he wrote.

“It is time to end the current era of political polarization and extreme partisanship. We must transform government together,” he asserted. “We must put aside the premise of ‘I’m right, you’re wrong.’ We must do what is right instead of doing what makes the other side look bad.”

His points are astute and accurate. The tendency, as it is at the national level, is to focus on personalities and not principles. It’s time to stop shooting the messenger instead of the message, and to be honest in campaigns.

For example, it took legal action by the Association of Washington to clean up the ballot title for Referendum 52. To win passage of $505 million in bonds for energy-saving school construction projects, the wording would have tricked voters into extending the new tax on bottled water. A Thurston County judge ruled that the phrase, “job creation,” was disingenuous and removed it from the ballot title.

Alleviating uncertainty

Voters have an opportunity to start implementing solutions this fall. The most salient is transparency and voter protection against disingenuous taxation. In essence, Initiative 1053 will again require a two-thirds majority on any legislative tax increase, and approval by voters.

I-1053 must be passed. Plus, voters have to make it clear to lawmakers that they will not put up with any more games.

Three times voters have passed this protection, and each time the Legislature has circumvented it.

Initiative 1082 deserves voter approval. It would pave the way for private insurers in Washington state workers’ compensation.

Liquor sale privatization is important, too, in I-1100. It would end the state’s monopoly on liquor sales and put it in the hands of the private sector. That includes the 1,500 state-liquor employees.

The class warfare implications of I-1098 are troubling. That’s the income tax on the affluent. A similar 2010 measure in Oregon has failed to help that state’s economy.

Another opportunity to alleviate uncertainty is to comment at two remaining events: The Governor’s Committee on transforming Washington’s Budget. So far, only the special interests advocating the status quo are showing up to comment.

The final two hearings:

  • July 27, 7-9 p.m. in Vancouver – Washington State University-Vancouver, Administration Building Room 110, 14204 NE Salmon Creek Avenue.
  • July 29, 7-9 p.m. in Spokane  – Spokane City Hall, City Council Chambers, 808 W. Spokane Falls Boulevard.

Will you participate.

Meantime, productive public policy will do a lot to alleviate concerns about business uncertainty, and will make it easier for businesspeople to solve their declining sales revenue.

From the Coach’s Corner, admittedly, I haven’t budgeted the time to review the dozens of initiatives on the November ballot, but have read a few others.

For some levity, here are two extreme initiatives:

  • I-1079 – “This measure states that it is an act to require state and governmental agencies, publicly owned companies, and non profit groups to pay all mandatory overtime at the rate of three times the employees’ hourly rate.”
  • I-1069 – “This measure would require the Seal of the State of Washington to be changed to depict a vignette of a tapeworm dressed in a three piece suit attached to the lower intestine of a taxpayer shown as the central figure. The seal would be required to be encircled with the following words: ‘Committed to sucking the life blood out of each and every tax payer.’ The illustration would be selected from submissions submitted by taxpayers.”

And to see dozens other public-policy columns, visit this section.

Seattle business consultant Terry Corbell provides high-performance management services and strategies.